Phebe Marble

1822 - 1856  (33 years)

• Name	Phebe Marble  [1, 2]
  Birth	11 Oct 1822  [1, 2]
  Gender	Female
  Death	21 May 1856	Romeo, Macomb Co, Michigan   [1, 2]
  Person ID	I2314	Cooley Miller Sears Barnhouse
  Last Modified	4 Feb 2022

  
  

  Family	Benjamin Cooley Sutherland,   b. 18 Jun 1810, Sutherland Falls, Rutland Co, Vermont d. 31 Jan 1867, Ray Twp, Macomb Co., Mich. (Age 56 years)
  Marriage	17 Sep 1840	Macomb County, Michigan   [2]
  	On 17 September 1840 Benjamin Cooley Sutherland married Phebe Marble who was born 11 October 1822 and died 21 May 1856. Benjanin Cooley Sutherland married second on 18 December 1856 Mandana Marble, Phebe's sister. Mandana was born 11 October 1826 and died 18 December 1908. [2]
  Children	1. Andrew Cooley Sutherland,   b. 17 Jul 1841, Ray Twp, Macomb Co., Michigan d. 20 Sep 1866, Romeo, Macomb Co, Michigan (Age 25 years)   2. Abigail Naomi Sutherland,   b. 15 Apr 1843, Hadley Twp, Lapeer Co, Michigan d. 16 Aug 1921, Hadley Twp, Lapeer Co, Michigan (Age 78 years)   3. Carroll Sutherland,   b. 30 Jun 1845, Ray Twp, Macomb Co., Mich. d. 11 Aug 1855, Ray Twp, Macomb Co., Mich. (Age 10 years)   4. Charles Sutherland,   b. 21 Nov 1847, Ray Twp, Macomb Co., Michigan d. 9 Apr 1926, Chelsea, Washtenaw, Michigan (Age 78 years)   5. Hannah Sutherland,   b. Abt 1849, Macomb County, Michigan d. Abt 1876, Oxford Cem, Oakland Co, Michigan (Age ~ 27 years)   6. Caroline M Sutherland,   b. 22 Feb 1852, Macomb County, Michigan d. 28 Sep 1855, Macomb County, Michigan (Age 3 years)   7. Addison Sutherland,   b. 5 Apr 1854, Macomb County, Michigan d. 1 Feb 1926, Elba, Lapeer Co, Michigan (Age 71 years)
  Family ID	F556	Group Sheet  |  Family Chart
  Last Modified	31 Mar 2021

  
  

• Notes

  The three censuses, 1850, 60, 70 are so badly inconsistent for this family that no accurate data can be drawn from them. In 1860, Addison and Louis are listed as aged 1 indicating they are twins yet Louis doesn't appear in the 1870. What happened? No Ancestry genealogy for Benjamin Cooley Sutherland and Phebe Marble clear this up. Then in the 1860 census, Hannah is listed as 6 years old (5 years short) yet correctly as 21 in the 1870 census.

  
  

• Sources

  [S566] Find A Grave website founder Jim Tipton, Findagrave, Gravstone in Procter Cem died 21 May 1856 aged 33y7m10d giving bd 11 Oct 1822 (Reliability: 3). [S465] Millie A. Owings, Sutherland, JW, (Unpublished, 1988. Repository: Proctor Free Library, 4 Main St, Proctor Vermont 05765 (802-459-3539) ), p29 (Reliability: 3).